Unless you gave away FREE INFLATABLE YOSHIS!!!!!!
I'm only on my third issue since returning to the Nintendo fold but looking at the subs page it looks like there's some awesome gifts, and my wall planner is up and becoming very handy for remembering family birthdays!
When you've got such a large audience you can't expect to please all the people all the time, so keeping going, not all gifts may appeal to me but I think, looking at them overall, that you're doing a swell job.
But oh oh!! As i've already said in the "free gifts" thread itself, I collected the first couple of years of ONM (up until after Chandra left, it went downhill after that
) and before that the NOM mag, and they had a big inflatable Chain Chomp, which came on loads of beach holidays with me and he lasted for a good four or five years! Photos are in the other thread, not gonna embarrass myself twice!